So when we both say that Trader Joe’s Lemon & Triple Ginger Snap Ice Cream may be some of the best ice cream we’ve ever had, that says one heckuva lot. Sandy stated between each bite, “There’s nothing good that can be said about it.” You are so right, wifey. The lemon ice-cream base is mildly lemony. It’s sweet, tangy, and not too citrusy. It compliments the triple ginger cookie dough that is dry-swirled in the mixture in the perfect balance. Triple Ginger Snaps by TJ’s are legendary. A delicious mix of fresh, crystallized ginger and ground ginger is made into cookie batter to create a ginger-spiced cookie. Although it is quite dry, it is easy to mix in lemony ice-cream. However, the consistency is good enough and the flavor is so delicious that it is hard not to love it. The ratio of cookie dough and ice cream is about right. The batter in our carton was quite thick, so it seemed a bit heavy. But, it wasn’t a problem for us. According to the side of the carton, each carton contains roughly 15 cookies worth of dough. This seems pretty accurate.
Sandy and I went through the entire quart in just two sittings. Yes, we do know it’s bad. Ice cream can kill you. Shame on us, yada yada yada. Right. Take a bite, then pick it up and put it down. It’s impossible to stop. For a two year old, it’s addictive enough to make Teletubbies scream. It’s impossible to not eat it unless you are a weird person who doesn’t like ice cream or if you are a monk who swears to avoid all forms of pleasure on earth. In that case, I would say you’re missing something.
This would have to be the best ice-cream I’ve ever tasted. Pantheon is shorthand for the highest ranking of the best. It’s not possible to compare it with others who have reached that level. This is the highest status possible and it’s not something to be taken lightly. It is a Hall of Fame within a Hall of Fame (think Billy Williams and Ted Williams). If I had to make an Ice Cream Mt. Rushmore, this would be right up there with the Creamery’s Peachy Paterno, Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia and Chubby Hubby, and the offbeat but incredulously good bacon and Trix** combo from Oh Yeah!. It is so good. If it makes it into the ice cream pantheon you can be sure it will make it to the WGaTJ. Five for me and five for my lady. I wish there were five more. It is probably a good thing that they don’t.
Bottom line: 10 Golden Spoons out of 10.
p.s. p.s. – Don’t forget our reader contest! Check out the rules to see what you could win and then check out the prizes. There are only one week left! How good are your chances !?!?!?
*Everyone who works at the Ben & Jerry’s factory gets three free pints of ice cream a day. They are also owned by Weight Watchers. This is a sustainable business model.
**Much better than the bacon and hops I had once, as well as the inadvertent wasabi that secretly snuck it’s way into my dish once. Talk about an unpleasant surprise.